The plagiarist

2011-06-28T19:00:00.000-07:00

Should Ratan Tata advise Mukesh Ambani about how to use his wealth?

A couple of days ago famous industrialist Ratan Tata commented about the lavish life style of another billionaire business tycoon Mukesh Ambani quoting his 27 storied Mumbai house viz., Antilla. Tata said that Mukesh Ambani's house Antilla represents the rich Indian's lack of empathy for the poor. His remarks: "The person who lives in there should be concerned about what he sees around him and [asking] can he make a difference. If he is not, then it's sad because this country needs people to allocate some of their enormous wealth to finding ways of mitigating the hardship that people have."

Is Ratan Tata right in his remarks or is he misguided in his judgements? Is he aware about the role of an entrepreneur in an economy or is he ignorant of this basic economic fact? Or is his remarks has some underlying assumptions which make those remarks perfectly apt for Mukesh's lifestyle? Let me deal with these questions one by one. I take two scenarios to carry out my analysis. In first scenario we assume that Mukesh Ambani is an honest entrepreneur and his profit comes from the market competition. In second scenario we assume that, Mukesh is not an honest entrepreneur and his profit comes from his business ties with government officials and his manipulation of the system of State. We see the implications of Ratan Tata's remarks under both these scenarios.

Scene 1: Mukesh is an honest entrepreneur

I first make an assertion and then go onto prove it. If Mukesh is an honest entrepreneur then his profit - which he earned in the market competition - is absolutely legitimate, and if he don't desire to do a philanthropist work then that is his voluntary choice. Ratan Tata has no right whatsoever to advise Mukesh about allocating his honestly hard earned wealth amongst the poor people or to comment on his lavish lifestyle.

As Ludwig von Mises explained, the only way in which an entrepreneur can make profit in the market competition is by serving and fulfilling the most urgent wants of his customers in the best possible way, and that best possible way is of providing top quality goods at the lowest possible price. Only those entrepreneurs succeed and make profit in the market process who can ascertain and fulfill the subjective wants of customers in the best way compared to his counterparts.

By producing and selling top quality goods at a lowest possible price successful entrepreneurs allow even the very poor people to buy his products. By allowing them to buy his products he lifts their standard of living; he lifts them out of their poverty even without raising their nominal meager income. That happens because with the falling prices in the market with the same amount of nominal income people can now buy more goods and services i.e., their real income rises. And no sane person will deny that this is the real way of increasing prosperity in the society; this is the true way of eliminating poverty and lifting the standard of living of millions of poor people.

Philanthropy, about which Ratan Tata is advising Mukesh, will only help poor people in a very short run i.e., for the urgent immediate consumption purposes. Such help to poor people will actually harm them in the long run by making them dependent on such easy free money. It will not cultivate any habit of hard work and independent living in those people. Redistributing the income will only exacerbate the problem of poverty because human nature is such that most people will always prefer the free goods. Such allocation of rich peoples' income will make everyone of us poor too because rich people play an important role of providing essential savings for the economy. And without savings it is impossible to sustain a labor population in present time which is involved in production of intermediate capital goods. And without capital goods it is impossible to increase the future production of final consumption goods, and without that progress (so-called growth) is not possible. Capitalist class - which includes people coming from all strata of society, and not just rich - plays a pivotal role of supplying this saving. If they are forced to allocate their saving to poor people, who will mostly use it for immediate consumption, then society and economy cannot progress and without progress everyone of us will be poor one day for sure.

And people should not forget another vital economic truth that, honest entrepreneur do not become rich by exploiting the public, but they are made rich by their consumers i.e., the same public. Consumers voluntarily buy the products sold by such sellers because they prefer their products over other sellers. And in this process they give their portion of income to these entrepreneurs making them rich in turn. Profit is a signal that the businessman is fulfilling the most urgent wants of his consumers in a best possible way, and that's why he is rich. On the other hand those entrepreneurs who make losses are not fulfilling consumers' wants properly and so they remain poor in turn by going broke! (to deeply understand the beautiful system of profit & loss I will advise my readers to read Mises' wonderful book, Profit and Loss).

So, if Mukesh is an honest entrepreneur then he has all the rights to keep and use his profit in whatever way he wants to.

Scene 2: Mukesh is a dishonest entrepreneur

But, if Mukesh Ambani is a dishonest entrepreneur and his profit comes solely from his friendships with the government bureaucrats and politicians then he has no right whatsoever on his wealth. Profit generated by such dishonest political maneuvering is immoral. In a system of government such businessmen are working not to serve their consumers but only to serve the politicians and bureaucrats who help them in restricting the market competition. They actively lobby government so to establish their monopolies in the market. Through these monopolies then they fleece the consumers. And because their profit depends on exploiting the political system they don't care about their consumers. In fact they go to any length to harm their consumers for making such illegitimate and immoral profits.

This type of system is historically known as 'fascism' and sadly in today's world most of the businessmen, especially the big business houses are making their fat profits by this way only.

If Mukesh Ambani (also Ratan Tata and all others) is doing his business in cahoot with the government officials then his profit is illegitimate. If one day India becomes truly a free country then he should be stripped of his illegal profits (property) and should be convicted and punished for his crimes against the people. He and all such dishonest business tycoons should be incarcerated, may be hanged.

Conclusion

Looking at these economic facts, if Tata and Mukesh both are honest businessmen and they really want to help people of this country then instead of allocating their profit to the poor people they should use that capital in producing top quality goods at the lowest possible price. They should try to provide as many economic goods as possible to people of India through market competition. Tata and Mukesh both can profit by serving the needs of poor people. There exists a thriving market even in remotest rural poor areas of the world as C. K. Prahalad has shown. All capable entrepreneurs (existing and new ones) should provide top quality private schools, hospitals, private roads, electricity, water works, sanitation, home etc. goods in these areas at the lowest possible price. That will be the best possible moral way of making a difference in poor peoples' lives; that is the only way in which these entrepreneurs can help the poor in mitigating their hardships. Allocation/redistribution of wealth will only result in misery for all of us.

1 comments:

kapil69 said...: it's not about being honest/dishonest? it's about show-off lavish life style in a locality which is deprived & it doesn't make sense at all. Every entrepreneur can't be like Bill Gates, i agree & there is no need to be. Ambani can purchase Al Burj or anything like that, nobody will ever comment on that.; May 27, 2011 6:24 AM

The Fourth of July

2010-07-04T22:02:00.001-07:00

The Fourth of July is especially dear to my family. For us, it is not just our nation's birthday. It is the day Michelle and I became parents 12 years ago. And I can't wait to watch the fireworks with Malia on her birthday tonight, as we do every year.

As we celebrate the profound pride of being American, today is a time to honor the women and men in our armed forces, whose immeasurable bravery and sacrifice have made our country what it is today.

That sacrifice is shared with husbands and wives, with sons and daughters, with fathers and mothers, who are asked to wait at home as their loved ones protect our nation. Their heroism, too, has helped pave the path of our freedom.

Even before we moved into the White House, Michelle was a champion for those military families. She has witnessed their struggles, and she has made it her personal mission to fight for them. On this Fourth of July, she recorded a personal message, commemorating our nation's birthday and paying tribute to these families.

Please take a minute to watch Michelle's video -- and join us as we honor our military families here and abroad:

http://my.barackobama.com/July4th

From all of us, happy Independence Day.

Thank you, and may God bless America.

President Barack Obama

July 4th, 2010

Night Life in GOA

2010-07-04T21:23:00.000-07:00

Feedback

Change City

Subscribe To Newsletter

EXPLORE ON MAP

Adhega, Calangute

Alfama, Dona Paula

Angaara, Candolim

Bon Appetit, Bardez

Caravela, Bardez

Cafe Azul, Dona Paula

Docaria, Dona Paula

Corina, Panaji

Guszti, Anjuna

Cream center, Panaji

QUICK LINKS FOR :
CONTACT:
- About
- Contact
- Help us improve
- For Other Queries (info@timescity.com)
POWERED BY:

Copyright © 2010, timescity.com (Times Group Property).
All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy.
Terms & Conditions.

Devika 4

2010-07-04T21:20:00.001-07:00

THURSDAY, JULY 1, 2010

Not me, Morpheus says :)

when bright flowers bloom
parchment crumbles, my words fade
the pen has dropped ...
~ Morpheus

***************

Photo courtesy: as per original copyright at:
http://7art-screensavers.com/flowerspro.shtml

WEDNESDAY, JUNE 30, 2010

cloudy

cloudy July skies-
the blues singing
a melody, so in-tune
with the nervy words
my pen scribbles

********

Photo courtesy: as per original copyright at:
http://www.graphicshunt.com/wallpapers/images/cloudy_sky-1794.htm

TUESDAY, JUNE 29, 2010

forest walk

forest walk
at sundown –a little brook
turns to torrent

*******

Photo courtesy: as per original copyright at:
http://www.fs.fed.us/r9/forests/allegheny/recreation/waterfalls/

MONDAY, JUNE 28, 2010

sunrays

sunrays filtering through
the clouds at dusk -
closing my eyes
to hear the song
in my heart

**********

Photo courtesy: as per original copyright at:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/9669636@N04/2480753795

SATURDAY, JUNE 26, 2010

winter jasmines

winter jasmines

a memory on the brick-wall,
robins whistling

********

Photo courtesy: Margaret Anne Clarke as per original copyright at:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/98799884@N00/2494891234

THURSDAY, JUNE 24, 2010

after the storm

after the storm
rain pressing on the window
. . . drips drop

through her
amethyst nose-ring

*********

Photo courtesy: audreyjm529, as per original copyright at:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/98799884@N00/2494891234

TUESDAY, JUNE 22, 2010

another

another long day ends,
along the western sky
tired frigates
head homewards
trailing the light

but, where's that little bird, who'd mock at me, in evenings like this?

***********

Photo courtesy: pvdos as per original copyright at:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/pdvos/104758065/

Devika 3

2010-07-04T21:19:00.001-07:00

The plagiarist

Should Ratan Tata advise Mukesh Ambani about how to use his wealth?

1 comments:

Post a Comment

The Fourth of July

Night Life in GOA

RECENT REVIEWS

SEARCH FOR A PLACE

RESTAURANTS THAT ARE

Devika 4

ABSTRACT DEDUCTIONS

THURSDAY, JULY 1, 2010

WEDNESDAY, JUNE 30, 2010

TUESDAY, JUNE 29, 2010

MONDAY, JUNE 28, 2010

SATURDAY, JUNE 26, 2010

THURSDAY, JUNE 24, 2010

TUESDAY, JUNE 22, 2010

A NOTE:

BLOG ARCHIVE

ABOUT ME

Devika 3

THE ESSENTIAL ME

WEDNESDAY, APRIL 21, 2010

FRIDAY, APRIL 2, 2010

FRIDAY, MARCH 12, 2010

SATURDAY, MARCH 6, 2010

WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 23, 2009

SATURDAY, DECEMBER 5, 2009

SATURDAY, AUGUST 8, 2009

A NOTE

ABOUT ME

MORE ABOUT ME

BLOG ARCHIVE

BLOGHOUNDS -- STAYING COOL

BLOGHOUNDS BLOGROLL

COPYRIGHT ©

SUBSCRIBE TO